A great newsletter feels personal and powerful. Here’s how to write a newsletter your audience will look forward to every week.
SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT:
Something Extraordinary is Coming
This November, The Wordling is launching a once-only opportunity for writers who plan to stay in the game for life.
Join the waitlist today. You won’t want to miss this.
If your inbox feels like a wild jungle, you’re not alone. Yet somehow, the best email newsletters still cut through the noise and actually get read—sometimes even enjoyed (gasp!). With social media reach shrinking and algorithms changing faster than you can say “refresh,” your newsletter is one of the last places you control the conversation.
Done right, a newsletter isn’t just another marketing blast—it’s the secret sauce behind loyal readers, stronger community, and campaigns that actually work. The challenge? Writing content so good your audience actually looks forward to seeing you land in their inbox (instead of reaching for the unsubscribe button).
Ready to turn your newsletter from “just another email” into the one your readers can’t wait to open? Let’s get into it.
Know your target audience
The best newsletters feel like they’re written just for you—not for some mysterious “mailing list” out in the ether. If you want readers to look forward to your emails, get specific about who you’re writing for.
- Define exactly who your reader is: Are you talking to freelancers, entrepreneurs, busy parents, or lifelong learners? The clearer your vision, the more relevant your content will be.
- Dig into what matters to them: Use surveys, quick polls, or your signup form to learn what keeps your audience interested, what they’re struggling with, and what delights them.
- Segment your email list: Group subscribers by interests, needs, or behaviors. Send deep dives to your die-hard fans, and snackable tips to the time-poor crowd.
- Match your tone to your people: Write the way your audience talks and thinks—whether that’s witty, warm, or straight to the point.
- Shape your content for them: Use what you know to craft compelling subject lines, choose the right newsletter templates, and deliver content that’s exactly what your readers are looking for.
📌 Pro Tip: Understanding your audience is the foundation of every successful newsletter and marketing campaign. When readers feel seen, your open and click rates soar—and your emails become the highlight of their inbox, not just another unread notification.
Behind every newsletter people love to open is a formula: just enough structure, plenty of personality, and zero fluff. Here’s what every winning edition needs:
- Craft an irresistible subject line: Your subject line is your first (and sometimes only) shot at grabbing your reader’s attention. Make it concise, compelling, and never spammy—think like a copywriter, not a clickbait artist.
- Reinforce with preheader and header: Use these as a second chance to hook the reader and preview your core message or best offer.
- Keep your content clear and valuable: Every section should deliver something your subscribers want—quick tips, curated links, exclusive product launches, or a great infographic. Stay focused, and always write with a conversational tone.
- Design for the real world: Most people check emails on their phones. Use a clean layout, strong visual hierarchy, and lots of white space so your newsletter is readable (and enjoyable) on any device.
- Use templates, but don’t get boring: Tools like Mailchimp and HubSpot help you create professional newsletters fast, but always add your brand’s flair. Cookie-cutter layouts? Not your style.
- Make your call to action obvious: Whether you want readers to click a link, buy something, or share your podcast, give them a clear, irresistible next step.
- Proofread every time: Typos and sloppy writing kill your credibility. Every. Single. Time.
📌 Pro Tip: Great newsletters are built on a blend of smart strategy, reader-first content, and a dash of your unique style. Nail these basics, and your weekly newsletter will become the highlight of your audience’s inbox.
Content that drives engagement and click-through rates
Keeping your subscribers hooked means serving up variety, value, and just enough surprise to make every email worth opening. Here’s how to craft content your readers can’t resist:
- Mix up your content types: Share a blend of personal stories, timely updates, curated links, exclusive offers, and the occasional step-by-step guide or tutorial. Variety keeps engagement (and open rates) high.
- Show real-world examples: Include mini case studies, user-generated content, or behind-the-scenes peeks at a product launch—people love seeing how things work in real life.
- Leverage copywriting tricks: Use urgency (“Only 24 hours left!”) or exclusivity (“This offer’s just for subscribers”) to nudge readers to click, buy, or reply.
- Choose your cadence wisely: A monthly newsletter or biweekly schedule keeps things fresh and relevant—unless you truly have high-quality content to share every single week. Less can be more if it means every email is a highlight.
- Always aim for relevance: Every piece of newsletter content should feel handpicked for your subscribers’ interests, needs, or goals.
📌 Pro Tip: By mixing up your newsletter content and focusing on genuine value, you’ll keep your email campaigns lively—and your subscribers looking forward to every edition.
Mastering the email subject line
If your newsletter doesn’t get opened, nothing inside it matters. Nailing the subject line is half the battle (and sometimes the whole war). Here’s how to get it right:
- Be clear, specific, and spark curiosity: A great subject line tells readers what’s inside and why it matters—without giving everything away. Don’t be afraid to pique curiosity, but never mislead.
- A/B test for the win: Even the pros (like HubSpot and Mailchimp) swear by split-testing different subject lines to see which ones get higher open rates. Let data—not just instinct—guide your choices.
- Skip the “salesy” jargon: Would you open an email that screams “LAST CHANCE TO BUY!”? Probably not. Focus on what feels relevant, interesting, or valuable to your actual subscribers.
- Look for inspiration in your own inbox: Think about the newsletters you actually read. What subject lines catch your eye? Borrow what works and make it your own.
- Keep SEO in mind: If your newsletter ties into a new product, trending topic, or search term, work that naturally into your subject line for extra digital marketing juice.
📌 Pro Tip: Mastering the subject line isn’t about tricking readers—it’s about giving them a reason to click, open, and dive into the content you’ve worked so hard to create.
A good newsletter isn’t just a collection of updates—it’s an experience. Here’s how to write one your subscribers actually want to read:
- Start with a hook: Grab attention from the first line, whether it’s a quick personal note, a thought-provoking question, or something a little unexpected.
- Make content scannable: Use headers, bullet points, and well-defined sections so readers can find what matters to them fast (and never feel overwhelmed).
- Focus on one clear CTA: Don’t overload your readers with choices. Whether it’s clicking a link, downloading a resource, or replying to a question, give them a single, strong call to action.
- Proofread—again: Typos and formatting issues kill your credibility, so always review your copy and preview on mobile devices before you send.
- Keep your email marketing strategy in mind: Every step, from structure to CTA, should serve your broader goals—delivering relevant content that keeps subscribers engaged and coming back for more.
📌 Pro Tip: Follow this process, and you’ll be known for writing good newsletters that feel like a highlight, not a chore, in your readers’ inboxes.
Measuring success: Metrics that matter
If you want your newsletter to keep growing (and keep working), you need to know what’s hitting the mark—and what needs a rethink. The right metrics show you what your audience really values.
- Track what counts: Keep a close eye on open rates, click-through rates, unsubscribes, and actual conversions (like signups, sales, or replies)—these numbers show whether your content is landing.
- Focus on engaged subscribers: A small, loyal email list is more powerful than thousands of disengaged contacts. Prioritize quality over quantity.
- Lean on analytics tools: Use Mailchimp, HubSpot, or your ESP of choice to dig into the data, spot patterns, and discover what’s working in each newsletter you send out.
- Refine with feedback and A/B tests: Ask for reader feedback and experiment with subject lines, content types, or CTAs. Let your real audience guide your next move—not just your gut.
📌 Pro Tip: Tracking the right metrics (and listening to your subscribers) is the difference between sending emails and building a thriving newsletter that grows on its own.
Growing your email list—without annoying your audience
No one likes being pestered with pop-ups or guilt-tripped into joining a list. The best newsletters grow because people want in—here’s how to make that happen:
- Focus on value, not volume: Attract newsletter subscribers with genuinely useful, relevant content—not endless spam or clickbait.
- Offer irresistible lead magnets: Give people a reason to sign up—think templates, discounts, exclusive guides, or early access to something special.
- Optimize your landing pages and sign-up forms: Make it easy (and tempting) to join your list. A clear headline, a simple form, and a clear description of what they’ll get works wonders.
- Deliver consistent value: The real “growth hack” is writing a newsletter worth reading every single time. When your type of content delights, your email list will grow—no gimmicks required.
📌 Pro Tip: If you focus on building trust and delivering value, you’ll attract the kind of email subscribers who look forward to every send (and actually stick around).
The best newsletters don’t just fill inboxes—they build real connections. If you want yours to stand out, keep it useful, concise, and genuinely enjoyable to read.
Need help getting there? Sign up for our free newsletter and get email templates, real-world feedback, and proven strategies delivered straight to you. It’s everything you need to turn readers into fans—and subscribers into customers.
SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT:
Something Extraordinary is Coming
This November, The Wordling is launching a once-only opportunity for writers who plan to stay in the game for life.
Join the waitlist today. You won’t want to miss this.
