Do You Need a Literary Agent? Here’s How to Decide

A literary agent can open doors—but not every door is worth walking through. Learn how to choose what’s right for you.

---

---

---

Here’s the lay of the land: if you want to publish with the big New York houses (think Penguin Random House and friends) or the prestige imprints that feed them, a literary agent is the front door, the map, and the bouncer who knows your name.

If you’re eyeing small presses or you’re happily self-publishing, the calculus shifts—you’re trading gatekeepers for control, timelines for autonomy, and a slice of the pie for the whole bakery (plus all the washing up).

This piece helps you make the call for your book and your career: when representation from a good literary agency accelerates the dream, and when DIY is the smarter, saner move. Grab a coffee; we’ll sort the romance from the reality.

---

What does a literary agent actually do?

A good literary agent is your deal-maker, strategist, and fluent translator of the publishing industry—not your ghostwriter, not your publicist. They turn a finished manuscript or nonfiction proposal into a targeted plan, then steer it through the publishing process so you land with the right editor at the right imprint. A good literary agent:

• Builds the submission strategy: Identifies editors and imprints, crafts the pitch, sequences waves, tracks reads, and adjusts after passes so momentum doesn’t die on page two of the inbox.
• Positions the project for the market: Refines hook, comps, and packaging so an editor instantly sees list fit in today’s publishing world.
• Translates category and audience: Places your book precisely—adult fiction, young adult, children’s books (middle grade, picture books), literary/commercial fiction, sci-fi, historical, narrative nonfiction—and targets the imprints that buy that lane.
• Guides editorial readiness: Gives pre-submission notes (structure, pacing, opening pages) and ensures the manuscript or proposal reads like an easy “yes.” Not ghostwriting—calibration.
• Manages submissions end-to-end: Handles guidelines, materials, timing, and communications; keeps editors reading and conversations moving.
• Negotiates the deal: Advances, royalties, option/reversion/non-compete, delivery/acceptance language, and subsidiary rights—protecting long-term value, not just the headline number.
• Expands rights and reach: Pursues audio, translation, and book club/large print; coordinates film/TV via co-agents when appropriate, turning one sale into multiple formats.
• Plans the career path: Advises on next-book choices, cadence, and brand—especially helpful for a new author building durable momentum.
• Coordinates the publishing timeline: Interfaces with editorial, legal, production, and marketing so milestones hit and surprises stay on the page, not in your inbox.
• Provides market intel in real time: Shares what editors are looking for now, which lists are shifting, and where your project has the best shot today—not last season.

That’s the job: pitch, position, prepare, submit, negotiate, expand, and steward—so your book doesn’t just get published; it gets placed where it can thrive.

📌 Pro Tip: When you’re choosing an agent, ask them to explain—plainly and briefly—who they’ll pitch and why, what polish they’d want before sending, and what happens if round one passes; if they can’t sketch a clear plan in real words, they probably don’t have one.

The pros of having a literary agent

An agent isn’t just a middle-person; they’re leverage. The right one gets your work in the right rooms, frames it so editors can say yes, and protects the value you’re building over multiple books. Here’s what that looks like in practice:

• Access to traditional publishing: Many Big Four and prestige imprints only read agented work. Agents know which editors want which kind of books (they live in MSWLs and deal sheets), and they can put your full manuscript or book proposal on the right desk the first time.
• Negotiation power: Better advances and saner contract terms—options, reversions, non-competes, subrights—because your agent negotiates those every week, not once a decade.
• Industry expertise: Smart editorial notes, sharp positioning, and timed submissions that match the market. From New York lunches to Publishers Marketplace tea leaves, they know who’s buying what now.
• Targeted category placement: Whether you write historical fiction, upmarket fiction, or nonfiction, they translate your project into the exact lane an imprint can acquire—and find comps that help it land.
• Career management, not just one deal: Build a list across formats and genres—next novel, short story collection, or nonfiction—plus kid-lit paths for illustrators. Agents think in arcs, not moments.
• Rights and reach: Audio, translation, large print, book club, and sometimes film/TV via co-agents—turning one sale into multiple income streams.
• Process shielding: They handle guidelines, submissions, and follow-ups so you can write while the wheels of book publishing grind.
• Signal boost for debuts: For fiction writers (and especially new writers), an agent’s reputation vouches for readiness before an editor even opens chapter one.
• Data you can use: Real intel on comps, positioning lines, and timing—grounded in actual editor conversations, not rumor threads and QueryTracker spreadsheets.

📌 Pro Tip: Before you sign, define your non-negotiables for an agent—how they communicate, how hands-on they are editorially, and how they run submissions—and let those standards, not the flattery, drive your choice.

The cons of having a literary agent

The right agent can be a force multiplier—but they also add another moving part to an already creaky machine. If you go in clear-eyed about the downsides, you’re less likely to confuse “has help” with “hands-off.”

• Hard to land representation: Querying is competitive and slow; passes can take months. A hungry new agent can be great, but you still spend real time in the queue.
• Commission: Standard 15% on domestic deals; foreign/film often involve co-agents, so your commission cut can rise to 20–25%. Over a career, that’s a meaningful slice.
• Quality varies: Not all agents sell your lane or communicate well. Red flags: reading fees, vague plans, or “we’ll see” energy. The wrong fit can stall you more than no agent.
• Less control over the submission plan: You don’t pick every editor or timing; you’re trusting their list, their relationships, and their read on when to push pause.
• Time cost of pre-submission edits: Many agents request revisions before going out. Helpful, yes—but it can add months, especially for debuts and nonfiction proposals.
• No guarantees: An agent improves odds; they don’t conjure acquisitions. You can spend a year on submission and still not sell.
• Prioritization is real: Busy agents triage. If you’re not the hottest project that week, responses slow and momentum can cool.
• Vision clashes: You want “weird literary with teeth”; they want “upmarket with a warmer hook.” Disagreements over comps, positioning, or even what to write next can drag.
• Career steering you may not want: Pressure to write to market, switch genres, or chase trends can bump against your long-term plan.
• Contract wrinkles still exist: Even with a strong negotiator, options, non-competes, or morality clauses can limit your next move.
• Accounting runs through the agency: Most payments route to the agent first; mistakes and delays sometimes happen before funds reach you.
• If they leave the agency, things get messy: You may have to choose to follow them, stay with the house, or split rights admin—none of which is fun mid-career.
• Access can narrow, too: Some small presses and niche imprints prefer direct author submissions; an agented-only approach might skip those paths.
• Energy sink if it’s not working: Breaking up, getting rights statements, and restarting the query cycle takes time you could have spent drafting the next book.

📌 Pro Tip: Before you sign, talk to two of the agent’s current clients—one debut, one midlist—and ask how the partnership feels month to month. Five candid minutes now can save you five frustrating years later.

When do you need a literary agent?

Let’s sanity-check the moment you bring in a pro. Some projects thrive with DIY hustle; others really do need a partner who knows which editors are hungry right now and how to get your pages to the top of their stack. If you nod along to any of the below, you’re in “query” territory.

• You’re aiming for a major house: Big Four imprints (and many prestige imprints) require agented submissions; an agent gets your work to the right editors at the right moment.
• Your category benefits from placement: You write commercial/adult fiction, literary fiction, YA, middle grade, children’s picture books, literary/upmarket, science fiction, or narrative nonfiction with real sales potential—and you need someone who knows which lists are buying your lane.
• You want strategic career guidance: You’d value editor intel, submission sequencing, and a partner who can shape not just this deal but the next three.
• You’re targeting bigger advances and better terms: You want a sharper negotiation for advances, royalties, reversion, option, non-compete, and sub rights.
• You see rights beyond the first sale: Audio, translation, book club/large print, and film/TV via co-agents are part of your plan—and you want someone to run those plays.
• You’d rather write than chase inboxes: Managing guidelines, nudging reads, and decoding contracts while drafting? Hard pass.
• You have momentum to capitalize on: A strong platform, contest win, viral serial, or high-concept hook needs timely placement with editors who can move fast.
• Your project needs precise positioning: You have comps, a hook, and a clear audience—but you want the best literary agents for your niche to package and pitch it where it will stick.
• Your nonfiction book is proposal-driven: You’re selling on platform + proposal and need access to the imprints that buy proposals frequently (and fight over them when they hit).

📌 Pro Tip: If you can name five specific editors or imprints that feel like a bull’s-eye for your book—and explain why in one line each—you’re in agent territory; if you can’t, an agent’s market map will earn its keep.

When you might not need an agent

Not every path runs through an agency office. If your goals lean toward speed, control, or very specific markets, you can skip the middle seat and still land the book deal that suits you—or publish without one. Here’s when going direct makes sense:

• You plan to self-publish: Self publishing is ideal for niche audiences, faster timelines, and authors who want control over cover, price, and launch calendar. You keep the data and steer every decision.
• You’re writing for academic/specialist niches: Many journals, university presses, and professional outlets take direct submissions and don’t expect agents. Your credentials and proposal carry the pitch.
• You prefer full control of rights: If owning every format (ebook, print, audio), setting prices, and running promos matters more than access to big publishing houses, DIY keeps the reins in your hands.
• You’re focused on short stories: Most magazines and many small/indie presses read unagented work. Submit directly, build credits, and decide later if you want representation for a collection.
• Your audience lives off Amazon/bookstore shelves: Courses, newsletters, Patreon, or direct sales may earn more (and faster) than a traditional route built for mass retail.
• You want to test-and-learn first: Pilot a novella or nonfiction mini with real readers, prove demand, then decide whether to query or keep scaling indie.
• You’re between projects and momentum matters: If the next release needs to drop on your schedule, waiting on submission cycles isn’t your friend.
• You’ve got a strong platform and a plan: If you already reach the readers directly—and enjoy the business side—an agent’s leverage may add less value than your agility.

📌 Pro Tip: Try a small “pilot” release—one short, well-packaged project published indie; if you love the business and the numbers move, keep steering, and if the admin drains you, that’s your cue to query.

How to find the right literary agent

Finding an agent is a business decision, not a vibe check. You want someone who understands your book, sells your lane, and communicates clearly. Here’s a straightforward path from “I think I’m ready” to “offer in hand” without the guesswork.

1. Define the target: Decide where you want the book to live (Big Five, mid-size, indie) and what you want from an agent (editorial input, career strategy, rights reach).
2. Polish the work: Finish the manuscript (for fiction) or a clean, market-savvy proposal (for a nonfiction book). “Almost there” is a time sink.
3. Build the pitch packet: Query letter, crisp one-line hook, title/genre/word count, 1–3 recent comps, short bio, and a tight synopsis. Opening pages shine.
4. Research the field: Find agents using Writer’s Digest, Writer’s Market, agency sites, and MSWL (Manuscript Wish List) pages to see who’s actively seeking your lane; note new-agent announcements—they’re growing lists.
5. Verify sales and taste: Read an agented book in your category, skim recent deals, and make sure their list matches your vibe (commercial, literary, upmarket, kid-lit, etc.).
6. Make a high-match list: Pick 10–20 agents who actually sell your kind of book. Quality over carpet bombing.
7. Tailor the query: Personalize the opener (“why you, why this”), keep the hook sharp, and make the comps do work (same audience, recent, same engine).
8. Obey the guidelines: Each agency has its quirks—attachments vs. paste, pages vs. chapters. The easiest rejection is “didn’t follow instructions.”
9. Send in small batches: Submit 5–7 at a time, track responses, and adjust the query or pages based on real feedback before the next round.
10. Manage requests professionally: If you get a partial or full, send promptly, label files clearly, and keep all parties updated if interest escalates.
11. Evaluate offers like a grown-up: Ask about submission strategy, editorial approach, communication cadence, and career vision. You’re choosing a partner, not a fan.
12. Check references: Quietly email two people from the agent’s current client list (ideally a debut and a midlister) to confirm experience matches the sales pitch.
13. Read the agreement: Clarify commission, termination terms, and sub rights handling. If you don’t understand a clause, ask until you do.
14. Close the loop: Accept the offer you want, then notify outstanding agents promptly and withdraw remaining queries.

Want a shortcut? Grab our UK + US agent roundup with recent sales and categories—handy for building that first, high-match list.

📌 Pro Tip: If you can’t picture your book on the same shelf as one title an agent already reps, they’re not your person—save the query for someone who is.

Alternative paths to publishing without an agent

You don’t have to go through an agent to get a book into readers’ hands. If your goals lean toward control, speed, or niche audiences, these routes can be smarter—and faster—than the submissions queue.

• Small presses and indie publishers: Many accept unagented work during open periods. Read the press’s backlist, match your category, and follow submission guidelines like gospel (format, word count, sample length, dates).
• Self publishing: Maximum control over timeline, pricing, metadata, and ads—with real-time sales data. Budget for professional editing, cover design, and formatting; the book has to look trad-quality to sell trad-quality.
• Hybrid publishing: Shared-cost models that provide editorial, design, and distribution. Vet contracts carefully (who owns the files and ISBNs? reversion terms? marketing promises vs. deliverables) and compare the total cost to going fully indie.
• Direct-to-audio or serial platforms: Audio originals and serialized fiction apps can be strong fits for commercial concepts; some accept direct pitches without representation.
• Anthologies, contests, and open calls: Creds, readers, and sometimes cash. Look for reputable organizers, clear rights terms, and themes that genuinely suit your work.
• University and niche presses: Especially for certain nonfiction and literary projects; many read directly and prize subject expertise over platform.
• Book-to-reader ecosystems: Build audience through newsletters, Patreon, or your own store; sell ebooks/audiobooks direct while using retailers for discovery.

📌 Pro Tip: Whatever path you choose, do a one-page “rights and reversion” check before signing anything—who owns what, for how long, and how you get it back. Clear exits make bold entries safer.

Find the path that fits your book

Publishing isn’t a single doorway; it’s a hallway with several good doors. If you want a shot at the big-house lists and a negotiator at your elbow, an agent makes sense; if you want speed, control, and direct reader feedback, indie can be a joy. Either way, the win is getting the right story to the right readers without losing your sanity.

If the agent door is the one you’re reaching for, start with names—not guesses. Our UK and US literary agents list, updated with recent sales and categories, gives you a head start so your query lands on the desks most likely to say yes.

---

---